Why would a frozen yogurt company with 51 locations in 15 countries pick a storefront on Second Avenue less than a block from Pinkberry, 16 Handles and Anita Gelato? Myka put up signage at 1547 Second Avenue, at East 80th Street, in the space Ania Rybka Salon used to occupy. As of Patch's September report, it had not announced an opening date.
On Friday, nearby at 1543 Second Avenue, also between 80th and 81st streets, the Chip City cookie shop went dark. The company closed every one of its stores that day.
So in the first week of October, the stretch of Second Avenue between 80th and 82nd streets holds one dessert shop that just closed, one that had not announced an opening as of September, and three established counters. That handful of storefronts explains the Upper East Side's frozen yogurt boom better than any trend piece. The new shops are not spreading out across the neighborhood. They are opening next to each other.
The Block Between 80th and 82nd
The table shows that stretch of Second Avenue as of the most recent local reporting.
| Address | Business | Last reported status |
|---|---|---|
| 1543 Second Ave., between E. 80th and 81st | Chip City | Closed Oct. 2 along with every other location |
| 1547 Second Ave., at E. 80th | Myka | Signage up, no opening date announced as of Sept. 8 |
| 1556 Second Ave., near E. 81st | Adria | Last service Sept. 12, owner looking to relocate |
| Second Ave., between E. 81st and 82nd | Pinkberry, 16 Handles, Anita Gelato | Operating as of Sept. 8 |
Patch counts two more shops, Yogurt Club and Sedutto, within a five-block radius of Myka's new address. That puts six frozen yogurt or gelato counters within a short walk of 80th and Second, and a seventh on the way.
Opening into that much competition only makes sense if the chain believes the lines will follow it, and its track record in Manhattan suggests they will. Myka already runs shops in the West Village, Union Square and Midtown. A June review in the New York Post put the wait at those locations at nearly half an hour, with servings costing $12 to $14.15. Those numbers come from downtown and Midtown, not from Second Avenue. East Side Feed's headline on the signage still called it a chain "with famously long lines."
Lexington Avenue Already Showed the Demand Was Here
Uptown demand stopped being a guess on Thursday, September 10, at noon. That was when Mimi's opened at 997 Lexington Avenue, at East 72nd Street. The Post described Mimi's as a viral Australian froyo shop, and this was its first uptown location. By 8:41 p.m. the following Monday, the line reached the corner of East 71st Street and staff were holding it in place with ropes. According to the Post, the line was made up of twenty-somethings in sweatpants and parents with young kids, and people waited nearly an hour.
The shop was not betting blind. Mimi's marketing director, Sam Rosensweig, told the Post that Upper East Side customers had been traveling downtown several times a week before asking for a shop closer to home. Founder Amber Linz described the store as a neighborhood "third space." Those customers had already been making the trip downtown, and Mimi's opened where they live.
The format is self-serve. Mimi's blends a Greek yogurt base with milk, kefir and a little cane sugar, rotates fruit flavors, and charges $1.20 per ounce. East Side Feed put a typical cup at $11 to $18. That range sits close to the $12 to $14.15 the Post reported at Myka's downtown counters. In practice, the price of a cup has settled in the low teens, and people are still waiting in line to pay it.
Three Months Earlier, Mythos Opened on First Avenue
Mimi's was not the first. Eater reported that Mythos opened at 1269 First Avenue on June 12. East Side Feed's story the day before announced the opening for "today at 3 p.m.," so the reports disagree by one day. Toppings run toward Greek pantry staples: baklava, honey, olive oil, fig and pomegranate. Eater priced them at $2 each, and its June roundup counted the Mythos opening as part of the Upper East Side becoming a frozen yogurt destination. On the day it opened, Upper East Site reported that neighbors were already lining up.
Put the three newcomers side by side and they are close to the same product. Mythos, Mimi's and Myka all start from Greek yogurt, and two of them add kefir. Myka uses goat's milk kefir and tops it with praline crunch, baklava, fig and orange compotes, pistachio sauce, honey and olive oil. Patch sets this tangy Mediterranean style apart from the sugary frozen yogurt that dominated the previous boom.
The Post's August look at the trend gave reasons that fit that product: Greek yogurt's high-protein reputation, upscale toppings, cups built for social media, and younger customers choosing to meet over dessert instead of at bars. Those reasons also help explain why the shops bunch together. When three competitors sell nearly the same cup, a shop wins by being the closest line, or the one people walk past on the way to another, and that pulls new arrivals toward each other.
The Route, South to North
For anyone who wants to compare them without crossing town, every shop above fits in a walk of roughly 16 blocks.
- Mythos, 1269 First Ave. The June opening, with baklava, fig and olive oil toppings at $2 apiece.
- Mimi's, 997 Lexington Ave. at East 72nd Street. Self-serve and priced by the ounce. The Post reported the heaviest rushes after school and after dinner.
- Myka, 1547 Second Ave. at East 80th Street. Signage up, with no opening date announced as of September.
- Pinkberry, 16 Handles and Anita Gelato, Second Ave. between East 81st and 82nd streets. Three counters on one block.
- Yogurt Club, 1240 Lexington Ave. between East 83rd and 84th streets. Greek yogurt and frozen yogurt with toppings you choose yourself. It turned up in a November 2025 roundup of new businesses, so it was here before the current wave.
- Sedutto, 1498 First Ave. Frozen yogurt on First Avenue, inside Patch's five-block radius of Myka.
For the shortest wait at Mimi's, go outside the after-school and after-dinner windows. The shop has also had to plan around its neighbors on Lexington. The Post reported that staff deliberately change the direction of the line once nearby businesses close for the night. On a block of apartment entrances and storefronts, managing the line is part of running the shop.
What Turns Over Around the Cluster
The froyo shops are arriving on a stretch of Second Avenue where other businesses have closed this fall. In its October 2 statement, Chip City wrote:
"Despite extensive efforts to stabilize the business in the face of significant macro-economic headwinds, we have made the very difficult decision to close all of our Chip City locations. We are grateful to our dedicated employees and loyal customers who have supported us for the past 10 years."
The chain had 24 locations in New York, New Jersey and Texas. It closed them all on the same day, so the Second Avenue shop went with them regardless of how it was doing on its own block.
Across the avenue at 1556 Second Avenue, near East 81st Street, Adria served its last customers on September 12. Owner Endri Qalliu told Patch that sales had fallen short of expectations, especially in the slower season, and that the partners were looking for another Upper East Side space. "We're looking to relocate," he said. They had not signed a new lease or set a reopening date.
So within three weeks, a cookie chain and a restaurant closed on the same short stretch, while a frozen yogurt chain known for long lines downtown put up its sign between them. As of the latest reporting, the block has two empty storefronts and one sign for a shop with no announced opening date. Whether Myka's opening day brings the half-hour waits it has downtown, or the ropes now outside Mimi's on Lexington, will be the next fact to report from 80th and Second.
Storefront turnover is one of the clearest early signals of how an Upper East Side block is changing, and it rarely shows up in a market report. If you'd like to talk through what the change on Second Avenue in the low 80s means for a building you own or are considering, Gina Sabio follows these corners closely and would be glad to walk them with you. Let's Connect.